Prepared in conjunction with Symposium, “Mathematization in Physics Lessons: Problems and Perspectives”, R. Karam and G. Pospiech, organizers. GIREP meeting, Leicester, UK, 18. August, 2009.
Abstract: Mathematics is an essential component of university level science, but it is more complex than a straightforward application of rules and calculation. Using math in science critically involves the blending of ancillary information with the math in a way that both changes the way that equations are interpreted and provides metacognitive support for recovery from errors. We have made ethnographic observations of groups of students solving physics problems in classes ranging from introductory algebra based physics to graduate quantum mechanics. These lead us to conjecture that expert problem solving in physics requires the development of the complex skill of mixing different classes of warrants – the ability to blend physical, mathematical, and computational reasons for constructing and believing a result. In order to analyze student behavior along this dimension, we have created analytical tools including epistemic frames and games. These should provide a useful lens on the development of problem solving skills and permit an instructor to recognize the development of sophisticated problem solving behavior even when the student makes mathematical errors.
No comments:
Post a Comment